Does Religion Cause War. Religion causes war. This is a matter of historical fact. Since time immemorial, men have fought each other in wars caused by religion. There are at least three instances by which religion causes war. The first is when people try to compel other people to adopt their religion or religious perspectives. This comes from our innate tendency to want Religion has its shares of promoting violence. Many will argue that a cause of religion wars is for economic and political reasons, but others argue that those who start wars are, by definition, not religious. In reality, separating religion out of economic and political motives can be involved in such a way finding religious motives innocent of much Religious certainty is not a cause of war, but religion and nationalism together have of ten been. Consequently religions, with all their claims to peaceableness, must be more intentional about not getting f astened with Nationalism
Does Religion Cause War? - Deadline Essay
To browse Academia. edu and the wider internet faster and more securely, please take a few seconds to upgrade your browser. Skip to main content. edu no longer supports Internet Explorer. Log In Sign Up. Download Free PDF. Does Religion Cause War?
Kennel Harrison. Download PDF. Download Full PDF Package This paper. A short summary of this paper. READ PAPER. I f ound Martin's discussion on the role of dif f erentiation in societies to be quite helpf ul.
Martin argues convincingly that pluralism, or social dif f erentiation, typically increases conf lict and tension. Martin writes that in a place where a single expression of a religion has long existed, its symbolic language in society has become organic and it has a rooted ethnic constituency. Changes pluralism! can be instigated by f orces f rom within society, as in the rise of voluntary f aiths, or f rom external f orces, such as immigration, colonialization, missionary activity, globalization, does religion cause war essay, etc.
As a Mennonite background Christian I have always been inclined to consider a dif f erentiated society a saf er place to be. T hat is, the more "organic" a given single religion is -especially a singular expression of that religion or ideology -the more dangerous it will be f or minority expressions of that religion, or f or another religion, to exist. However, Martin points out that when change dif does religion cause war essay erentiation is introduced in a place where a single expression of religion has long existed, this is of ten the occasion f or conf lict.
T his point reminded me of an "aha" moment when I was studying ecclesiology in a Catholic classroom setting. As I listened to the discussion that day, does religion cause war essay, I f elt my stomach drop as empathy allowed me to see f rom their point does religion cause war essay view, how threatening an Anabaptist might have been in the 16 th century.
I was f orced to reconsider my then viewpoint that 16 th C. Catholicism was a source of violence and consider how my ancestors were experienced as a threat. By looking at Romania and England Martin illustrates how "ethno-religion is itself an ambiguous phenomenon in the promotion of f ull pluralism" because it is going to want to promote itself as a centre -a political centrethereby marginalizing "rivals in its own heartland" T his idea did not come as a surprise to me, indeed it reinf orced my worldview, but Martin surprised me by observing how voluntaristic traditions, with their emphasis on "peaceableness and social orderliness through expectation of obeying the rules" -by marginalizing themselves -also disrupt the ability to build healthy dif f erentiated societies In both types of religious phenomena, the ethno-religious majority or the voluntaristic minority, can be "harnessed" by political power to "protect" their identities, and this generates conf lict, even wars.
Does religion cause war essay had assumed that only a voluntaristic f orm of religion can guard against being co-opted by nationalist power, and was the only religious expression capable of dissent. But Martin shows that neither f orm of religious expression, no matter how peaceable their teachings, is risk-f ree f rom either def ending power, or f rom being a source of protest and dissent.
As Martin states, any f orm of religious expression "can go with the f lag or against it" What seems at stake in the question of whether religion causes war is recognizing the ways in which a religion relates to "centre and periphery" with the centre being national identity, national power, and nationalism, does religion cause war essay. We can look to history and see both cases; where a religion "was woven into a poorly dif f erentiated society, where roles of cleric and soldier might well on occasion be conf used" and to other places where a religion gave "a distinctive logic and a grammar" of transf ormation and peaceableness T he "special circumstances under which those who prof ess peace will, in f act, practice violence," writes Martin, has does religion cause war essay to do with how co-extensive that religion is with the nation, how co-extensive it is with society, "and thus with the dynamics of power, violence, control, cohesion, and the marking of boundaries" Nationalism is the cause of war in three ways: when it has a territorial sense, when it has a religious ideological dimension, and when it has an ethnic or social dimension.
Religious certainty is not a cause of war, but religion and nationalism together have of ten been. Consequently religions, with all their claims to peaceableness, must be more intentional about not getting f astened with Nationalism. Susan HarrisonI am a PhD candidate at the Toronto School of T heology -Emmanuel College at the University does religion cause war essay Toronto. In addition to my current research in Christian Peace T heology and the T heology of Religions I teach, participate in and organize Interf aith dialogue events.
I have an MDiv and a T hM in New Testament and have f ound leading Scriptural Reasoning groups a meaningf ul way of connecting with people, building community, and learning about how scripture shapes lives does religion cause war essay gives meaning to people. I have served in dif f erent capacities as a pastor, does religion cause war essay and a cultural exchange program coordinator. Subscribe to this author. Related Papers. Peace in Orthodox Liturgy and Life.
By Fr, does religion cause war essay. Philip LeMasters. By Centre for Democracy And Development. Bah, Abu Bakarr. By Abu Bah. Download pdf. Log In with Facebook Log In with Google Sign Up with Apple. Remember me on this computer. Enter the email address you signed up with and we'll email you a reset link, does religion cause war essay.
Need an account? Click here to sign up. About Press Blog People Papers Job Board Advertise We're Hiring! Help Center Find new research papers in: Physics Chemistry Biology Health Sciences Ecology Earth Sciences Cognitive Science Mathematics Computer Science.
Terms Privacy Copyright Academia ©
Do Religions Really Cause Violence?
, time: 6:33Does Religion Cause War - Academic Essay Writers
Oct 06, · Religion has dominated every aspect of life for centuries, primarily through indoctrination, and it is through this that religion is seen as a cause of war. Religion was the cause of drawing of borders where some people considered themselves unique and different based on the differences in matters concerning their blogger.comted Reading Time: 5 mins Religion has its shares of promoting violence. Many will argue that a cause of religion wars is for economic and political reasons, but others argue that those who start wars are, by definition, not religious. In reality, separating religion out of economic and political motives can be involved in such a way finding religious motives innocent of much Religious certainty is not a cause of war, but religion and nationalism together have of ten been. Consequently religions, with all their claims to peaceableness, must be more intentional about not getting f astened with Nationalism
No comments:
Post a Comment